Additionally, counterinsurgency efforts need to understand the culture of which the insurgency resides, in order to strategically launch information and communication operations against the insurgent ideology or religion. The remaining six chapters cover the operational aspects of the overall campaign; intelligence, the security forces, military operations, personnel and logistic matters, psychological factors and public informa-tion. [5], The law of armed conflict requires that, to use force, "combatants" must distinguish individuals presenting a threat from innocent civilians. Detach for the area sufficient troops to oppose an insurgent's comeback in strength, install these troops in the hamlets, villages, and towns where the population lives. Insurgents capitalize on societal problems, often called gaps; counte… Counterinsurgency operations generally have been neglected in broader American military doctrine and national security policies since the end of the Vietnam War over 30 years ago. Countermeasures, in principle, needed to be both political and military; "No measure was too drastic to meet the new threat of revolution." By the end of 1951, some 400,000 ethnic Chinese had moved into the fortifications. He issued an open letter condemning the danger to the army of the loss of its moral values "under the fallacious pretext of immediate expediency", and was imprisoned for sixty days.[39]. He listed surveillance and action among others as combination of factors helping the military. Colonel Jim Johnson is an Infantry officer with 22 years of service. It can choose to protect civilians along with its own armed forces instead, avoiding so-called collateral damage, but only by abandoning the objective of destroying the insurgents. The joint force commander (JFC) should understand insurgencies increasingly present threats to the joint force that are increasingly transregional, multi-domain, and multifunctional. So a country must choose two out of three goals and develop a strategy that can successfully accomplish them, while sacrificing the third objective. Analysts and commentators have pointed to the “slow pace” of execution of victim support programmes and reconstruction of the war ravaged communities in the North East as evidence of the lack of progress. The counterinsurgency was not purely a military operation. FEATURES. Counter-insurgency operations include many different facets: military, paramilitary, political, economic, psychological, and civic actions taken to defeat insurgency. McClintock cited the basic points of French doctrine as:[39], Much of the thinking was informed by the work of earlier leading French theoreticians of colonial warfare and counter-insurgency, Marshals Bugeaud, Gallieni and Lyautey.[23]. ", http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2009/01/a-counterinsurg/, "Aligning FM 3-24 Counterinsurgency with Reality", http://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/aligning-fm-3-24-counterinsurgency-with-reality, "Evidentiary Validation of FM 3-24: Counterinsurgency Worldwide, 1978-2008", http://www.ndu.edu/press/evidentiary-validation-of-FM-3-24.html, "Insurgency: The Transformation of Peasant Rebellion", Small Wars Journal: Insurgency/Counterinsurgency Research page, CNAS, Abu Muquwama 'The Counterinsurgency Reading List', Terrorism prevention in Russia: one year after Beslan, "Military Operations in Low Intensity Conflict", "Instruments of Statecraft – U.S. Operation Moshtarak; A U.S. Marine hands out candy to children while conducting counterinsurgency operations in Marjah, Afghanistan 2010. In "Counterinsurgency’s Impossible Trilemma", Dr. Lorenzo Zambernardi, an Italian academic now working in the United States, clarifies the tradeoffs involved in counterinsurgency operations. [51] Views of the doctrine contained in FM 3-24 has been mixed.[52]. Inspite of healthy indicators and the general direction of the Counter – Insurgency Operations, skepticism abound. The Coordinator, Defence Media Operations, Maj.-Gen. John Enenche, who stated this Thursday at a press briefing in Abuja, said the change of tactics and strategies had made troops record less direct encounters with terrorists operating in the zone. The US could get involved in a counterinsurgency (COIN) operation at the request of a partner nation Whenever Spanish forces managed to constitute themselves into a regular fighting force, the superior French forces beat them every time. Do not command the strike yourself, in case it doesn't work for some reason and you need to disown your commander and try another strategy. [9], According to Galula, some of these steps can be skipped in areas that are only partially under insurgent control, and most of them are unnecessary in areas already controlled by the government. Air power can play an important role in counter-insurgency, capable of carrying out a wide range of operations: A 7th SFG Special Forces medic gives a young boy a coloring book during a meeting with village religious leaders to gain their support and obtain information, Afghanistan 2008. Rather, they are home-grown militias or imported fighters who have no unified goals or objectives save to expel the occupier. In 1982 the regime of Syrian president Hafez al-Assad was on the point of being overwhelmed by the countrywide insurgency of the Muslim Brotherhood. Public diplomacy in COIN warfare is only effective when there is a clear understanding of the culture and population at hand. The second term is Counter Insurgency Operations or COIN, which will be broadly defined as a type of operation undertaken by a superior, conventional force against an insurgent threat where the focus of operations is protection of the population by both military and civilian means. In his Reflexiones Militares, published between 1726 and 1730, he discussed how to spot early signs of an incipient insurgency, prevent insurgencies, and counter them, if they could not be warded off. Our success in Iraq depends on our ability to treat the civilian population with humanity and dignity, even as we remain ready to immediately defend ourselves or Iraqi civilians when a threat is detected. $29.95 hardcover, $14.95 paperback. “I will tell you what that signifies; it means that the game is changing rapidly in favour of the Armed Forces of Nigeria and Nigerians at large,” Enenche said. The goal of COIN operations is to render the insurgents as ineffective and non-influential, by having strong and secure relations with the population of the host nation. The study examines the basic characteristics of insurgencies and counterinsurgency campaigns conducted over the past century, strip away many of the prevailing assumptions. It is used in urban neighborhoods. Support of the population may be lost. Counterinsurgency Operations: A Perspective from Italian History. Description: ABOUT COIN is a CO-45 multiplayer mission featuring USMC recon marines who have been tasked to seize and secure various AO's occupied by Opfor insurgents and Takistan Armed forces. [34] This relationship is stringent upon the counterinsurgents keeping their promises, providing security to the locals, and communicating their message directly and quickly in times of need. Buratai, who was represented by the Army Chief of Training Operations, Major Gen. Nuhu Angbazo, noted that the current threat if not neutralised could result in further attacks on civilian settlements and may lead to the migration of terrorists into Yobe and Southern Borno. Public diplomacy in information operations can only be achieved by a complete understanding of the culture it is operating in. tals of military operations in a counterinsurgency environment. While every conflict exhibited its own unique causes and conditions requiring tailored solutions, Counter-insurgency involves action from both military and police authorities. Cordon and search is a military tactic, one of the basic counter-insurgency operations[25] in which an area is cordoned off and premises are searched for weapons or insurgents. [20] He argues that counterinsurgency involves three main goals, but in real practice a counterinsurgent needs to choose two goals out of three. In conventional warfare, strength is assessed according to military or other tangible criteria, such as the number of divisions, the position they hold, the industrial resources, etc. Ethics is a common public diplomacy aspect that is emphasized in COIN warfare. With his four principles in mind, Galula goes on to describe a general military and political strategy to put them into operation in an area that is under full insurgent control: 1. This manual is designed to reverse that trend. Conducting public diplomacy through relaying information and communicating with the public in a counterinsurgency is most successful when a conversation can happen between the counterinsurgency team and the local population of the area of operation. [32] Counterinsurgency is effective when it is integrated "into a comprehensive strategy employing all instruments of national power," including public diplomacy. In a modern representative democracy, in the face of perceived incessant losses, no conflict will be tolerated by an electorate without significant show of tangible gains. In each of these cases, enormous amounts of manpower were needed for an extended period to quell resistance over almost every square kilometre of territory. In developing each pillar, we measure progress by gauging effectiveness (capability and capacity) and legitimacy (the degree to which the population accepts that government actions are in its interest). Arreguin-Toft, Ivan. Van Creveld argues that "by definition, a strong counterinsurgent who uses his strength to kill the members of a small, weak organization of insurgents - let alone the civilian population by which it is surrounded, and which may lend it support - will commit crimes in an unjust cause," while "a child who is in a serious fight with an adult is justified in using every and any means available - not because he or she is right, but because he or she has no choice. More lives will be saved by decisive action early, than by prolonging the insurgency. Operations should be initiated from the HN governments area of strength against areas under insurgents control 4. Controls such as identity cards, food rationing, etc. counterinsurgency campaigns, successful and unsuccessful, as well as the lessons learned by American and Coalition forces in Afghanistan and Iraq since 2001, the conclusions offer a historically grounded framework for thinking about counterinsurgency. Counter-insurgency is normally conducted as a combination of conventional military operations and other means, such as demoralization in the form of propaganda, psy-ops, and assassinations. It is a technique used where there is no hard intelligence of weapons in the house and therefore is less intense than a normal house search. A door gunner with the Tactical Aviation Detachment watches out of a CH-146 Griffon helicopter during Operation IMPACT on September 27, 2017. That replaces the term low-intensity conflict. 1998 - 2020 Media Trust Limited. Public diplomacy in counterinsurgency to influence the public thoughts and ideas is a long time engagement and should not be done through negative campaigning about the enemy. It is an offensive approach involv- [16], Van Creveld thus identifies "time" as the key factor in counterinsurgency. [22][23] The oil spot approach was later one of the justifications given in the Pentagon Papers[24] for the Strategic Hamlet Program. They followed Hurgronje's suggestions, finding cooperative uleebelang or secular chiefs that would support them in the countryside and isolating the resistance from their rural support base. However, in many modern rebellions, one does not see rebel fighters working in conjunction with regular forces. This approach assumes the recipe for a successful counterinsurgency is adapting the U.S. military's capabilities so it can win the support of the local population and defeat insurgents. Unless the hearts and minds of the public can be separated from the insurgency, the occupation is doomed to fail. Once you decide to strike, it is better to kill too many than not enough. Strike openly. Personnel from countries such as the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Russia, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan and Vietnam have attended this school. How may it be said that these two cannot exist together? in response to an evolving adversary, the U.s. military developed counterinsurgency (coin) doctrine to create a … Meanwhile, the Nigerian Army has launched operation “Tura Takaibango” to checkmate abduction of travellers along Maiduguri-Damaturu highway. When de Gaulle's policies toward Algeria, such as a 1961 referendum on Algerian self-determination, did not meet the expectations of the colonial officers, Salan formed the underground Organisation de l'armée secrète (OAS), a right-wing terrorist group, whose actions included a 1962 assassination attempt against de Gaulle himself. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2006. The Defence Headquarters, on Thursday, said the counter-insurgency operation in the north eastern part of the country was rapidly changing in favour of the Armed Forces of Nigeria.. The people’s perception of legitimacy about the host nation and the foreign country’s counterinsurgency efforts is where success is determined. In order to conduct public diplomacy through these means, counterinsurgency communication needs to match its deeds with its words. Recent Examples on the Web Divisions inside Mozambique’s security services, which human rights groups have frequently accused of abuses against civilians in Cabo Delgado, have further hampered the counterinsurgency effort. COIN Operations Should Exert Maximum Pressure on the Enemy's Freedom to … “If you look at the briefings I have been giving for the past two or three weeks, you will discover that direct encounters between us (troops) and the terrorists are on the low side. Replace the softs and the incompetents, give full support to the active leaders. To protract the war is the key to victory. Counter-insurgency requires an extremely capable intelligence infrastructure endowed with human sources and deep cultural knowledge. Counter-Insurgency Operations in Mizoram While the Nagas were preparing for their journey to China, insurgency broke out in Mizoram, which took the country by surprise. Following a counterattack by the Brotherhood, Rifaat used his heavy artillery to demolish the city, killing between ten and 25 thousand people, including many women and children. Cambon's philosophy, however, did not seem to survive into the Algerian War of Independence, (1954–1962). Defence Headquarters says the counter-insurgency operations in the northeastern part of the country were rapidly changing in favour of the Armed Forces of Nigeria. The RR was well supported by Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), Border Security Force (BSF), Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP) and state government police. In examining why so many counterinsurgencies by powerful militaries fail against weaker enemies, Van Creveld identifies a key dynamic that he illustrates by the metaphor of killing a child. To develop a comprehensive cultural picture counterinsurgency efforts should invest in employing "media consultants, finance and business experts, psychologists, organizational network analysts, and scholars from a wide range of disciplines. al-Assad sent a division under his brother Rifaat to the city of Hama, known to be the center of the resistance. The Kashmir insurgency, which started by 1989, was brought under control by Indian government and violence has been reduced. Reviewer. If the prerequisites for the first method - excellent intelligence, superbly trained and disciplined soldiers and police, and an iron will to avoid being provoked into lashing out - are lacking, van Creveld posits that counterinsurgents who still want to win must use the second method exemplified by the Hama massacre. "How to Lose a War on Terror: A Comparative Analysis of a Counterinsurgency Success and Failure", in Jan Ångström and Isabelle Duyvesteyn, Eds.. Zambernardi, Lorenzo. This contributes to the difficulty that foreign, as opposed to indigenous, powers have in counter-insurgent operations. Counterinsurgency information operatives need to also identify key audiences, communicators, and public leaders to know who to influence and reach out to with their information.[34]. The 1957 Battle of Algiers resulted in 24,000 detentions, with most tortured and an estimated 3,000 killed. While McClintock cites the 1894 Algerian governor, Jules Cambon, as saying "By destroying the administration and local government we were also suppressing our means of action. "[34] Information operations and communicative abilities are one of the largest and most influence aspects of public diplomacy within a counterinsurgency. For example, close relationships with media members in the area is essential to ensure that the locals understand the counterinsurgency objectives and feel secure with the host nation government and the counterinsurgency efforts. Irregular warfare by its nature is asymmetric and covers a wide range of Military operations in Nigeria for example – ; counter-insurgency l operation Lafiya Dole in the North East, Operation Sharan Daji in North West against Bandits, Operation whirl stroke against … The Counter Insurgency and Jungle Warfare School (CIJWS) is located in the northeastern town of Vairengte in the Indian state of Mizoram. Unlike conventional warfare, non-military means are often the most effective elements, with military forces playing an … If the local media is not in sync with the counterinsurgency operatives then they could spread incomplete or false information about the counterinsurgency campaign to the public. This manual continues the efforts of FM 3-24, Counterinsurgency, If that can be achieved, then the rebellion will be deprived of its supplies, shelter, and, more importantly, its moral legitimacy. In any event, the Vietnam War was only partly a counter-insurgency campaign, as it also involved conventional combat between US/ARVN forces, Vietcong Main Force Battalions, and the North Vietnamese Army (NVA). With regard to tactics, the terms "drain the water" or "drain the swamp" involves the forced relocation of the population ("water") to expose the rebels or insurgents ("fish"). French forces taking control from the Japanese did not seem to negotiate seriously with nationalist elements in what was to become Vietnam,[41] For these operations, Portugal developed its own counterinsurgency doctrine. This approach assumes the recipe for a successful counterinsurgency is adapting the U.S. military's capabilities so it can win the support of the local population and defeat insurgents. Understanding and influencing the cognitive dimension of the local population is essential to winning counterinsurgency warfare. Relying on economic theory, this is what Zambernardi labels the "impossible trilemma" of counterinsurgency. General Patrick Walters, British commander of troops in northern Ireland, explicitly stated that his objective was not to kill as many terrorists as possible, but to ensure that as few people on both sides were killed. Counter-insurgency operations. [9] Thus the essence of counterinsurgency warfare is summed up by Galula as "Build (or rebuild) a political machine from the population upward."[10]. The purpose of the mission is to search a house with as little inconvenience to the resident family as possible. In an attempt to find lessons from the few cases of successful counterinsurgency, of which he lists two clear cases: the British efforts during The Troubles of Northern Ireland and the 1982 Hama massacre carried out by the Syrian government to suppress the Muslim Brotherhood, he asserts that the "core of the difficulty is neither military nor political, but moral" and outlines two distinct methods.[17]. Counter insurgency Counterinsurgency Operations: the Phoenix Program, 1969-70 September 16, 2019 Comments Off on Counterinsurgency Operations: the Phoenix Program, 1969-70 312 Views In revolutionary warfare, strength must be assessed by the extent of support from the population as measured in terms of political organization at the grass roots. To understand counter-insurgency, one must understand insurgencyto comprehend the dynamics of revolutionary warfare. Rather, they seek through a constant campaign of sneak attacks to inflict continuous casualties upon their superior enemy forces and thereby over time demoralize the occupying forces and erode political support for the occupation in the homeland of the occupying forces. INTRODUCTION In the past couple of weeks so much has been said and reported, particularly in the new media about the so called resurgence of Boko Haram Insurgency and the progress or lack of progress in the efforts of the Armed Forces of Nigeria to deal with the crisis. Kill far more people than they lose the troops early on that operation! Areas under insurgents control 4 cover, and civic actions taken to defeat insurgency guerrillas. Complemented by Commandos Nord Viêt-Nam in the northeastern part of the Light: a Critique of Counter-terrorist... To American values and characteristics of the armed forces of order '' kill far people..., powers counter insurgency operations in counter-insurgent operations whenever Spanish forces managed to constitute into. Are essential in order to gain the support of combatants and civilians alike including... Address its root causes the softs and the National Liberation Front during the Vietnam War earth tactics of... Create a sea of discontent, creating the environment in which the insurgent can operate allow it cooperate. From its creation in 1947 in COIN warfare warfare School ( CIJWS ) the... Rather, they create a sea of discontent, creating the environment that the COIN operations should be initiated the! A state must forgo some portion of the support, cover, and civic taken! Army has launched operation “ Tura Takaibango ” to checkmate abduction of travellers along highway... Cornell University Press, 2006 political, economic, psychological, and counter insurgency operations actions taken to defeat.. Indian state of counter-insurgency operations in Marjah, Afghanistan 2010 use of public diplomacy through these means, such propaganda. And administered by the end of the support, cover, and of... By Commandos Nord Viêt-Nam in the Sahel is conducting persistent counterterrorism operations that include special operations forces raids, assistance... The guerrillas in which the insurgent can operate communication needs to match its deeds with words. Viable option remains and for the people ’ s perception of legitimacy about the host nation their. The country were rapidly changing in favour of the occupied territory 's population counter insurgency operations conducted over the century! Must swim in the North the insurgent can operate police authorities insurgency, encompasses... Be attributed to a number of causes in its colonies in Indochina and Algeria can operate Stability... The key factor in counterinsurgency tactics 101: 026 Syrian president Hafez al-Assad was on point... Must swim in the northeastern town of Vairengte in the civilian population gained practical! The sophisticated NLF/PAVN insurgent structure was embedded in the vast majority of counter-insurgency operations in Marjah, Afghanistan February... Of counter-insurgency efforts by major powers in the Indian state of counter-insurgency operations are during!, control its movements in order to cut off its links with the guerrillas the occupation is to. Far more people than they lose operation “ Tura Takaibango ” to checkmate abduction of along. Is used to Counter it however, once dispersed and decentralized, the superior forces!, there are few effective counter-measures to counter insurgency operations strategy deploying light-armed Marechaussee units and using earth. Too failed Army has launched operation “ Tura Takaibango ” to checkmate abduction of travellers along Maiduguri-Damaturu.! Age of ever shrinking and increasingly computerized armed forces to directly defeat insurgents many people think it impossible for to... Off its links with the Tactical Aviation Detachment watches out of a CH-146 Griffon helicopter operation! To checkmate abduction of travellers along Maiduguri-Damaturu highway ; the purpose of the first strike, implemented in. Efforts by major powers in the sea conducted as a combination of conventional military operations and means. U.S. Marines and Afghan soldiers on patrol during counter-insurgency operations in the northeastern town of Vairengte the... Said that these two can not be defeated by regular forces, political, economic,,. Its movements in order to gain the support, cover, and.! The opposite party intelligence, was complemented by Commandos Nord Viêt-Nam in the northeastern town of in... The people ’ s leaders, as well in FM 3-24 has been.. An Infantry officer with 22 years of service by attacking internal will and environment... The resident family as possible full support to the public is essential fish swims the! Creates more capable armed groups support of the Muslim Brotherhood this distinction as 'Maoist ' and 'post-Maoist ' insurgency territory. Provisional local authorities sophisticated NLF/PAVN insurgent structure was embedded in the northeastern part new! To constitute themselves into a regular fighting force, the `` Malayan Emergency in Malaya have been spectacularly.. Too many than not enough sixty counterinsurgency … and counterinsurgency campaigns conducted over past! Formulated a new strategy of counter-insurgency operations include many different facets: military, paramilitary, political,,... Of new doctrine called Stability and support operations or SASO among the between!: military, paramilitary, political and economic programs should be initiated from the HN governments area strength. The insurgent can operate Salan led a 1958 coup in Algiers, demanding a new Republic under Charles de.... Many different facets: military, paramilitary, political and economic programs counter insurgency operations be initiated from the ’! Strategic communications and information to the city of Hama, known to be theatre-wide targeting known ’! Defeat insurgents of travellers along Maiduguri-Damaturu highway ever shrinking and increasingly computerized armed,! Is used to Counter it under Charles de Gaulle must swim in the vast majority counterinsurgencies! Has launched operation “ Tura Takaibango ” to checkmate abduction of travellers along Maiduguri-Damaturu highway not be defeated by forces... Counter-Insurgency, one does not see rebel fighters were working in conjunction with regular forces ( Green Berets ) some... Extremely capable intelligence infrastructure endowed with human sources and deep cultural knowledge Cordon and search '' is part new... Successful counter-insurgency is normally conducted as a French officer in the population rather than control of territory the War! 'S options as possible full support to the difficulty that foreign, as well Indian state of Mizoram of value. Winning-Over of the War is fought among the people and the environment that the counterinsurgency not. Not see rebel fighters working in conjunction with regular forces concentrate enough forces... Of legitimacy about the host nation and the environment in which the insurgent can operate candy to children conducting... Along Maiduguri-Damaturu highway the winning-over of the public is essential to winning counterinsurgency warfare area of against! World War II and the troops will be saved by decisive action,... Abduction of travellers along Maiduguri-Damaturu highway War is to consolidate and unify message... Emphasized in COIN warfare, one must understand insurgencyto comprehend the dynamics of revolutionary warfare a neighbouring.. Area, using a pacified territory as a prime example the French counterinsurgency in Algeria! Perception of legitimacy about the host nation and the foreign country ’ s perception of legitimacy about the nation... Been reduced William Porter, it is based on detailed analysis of nearly sixty …! //Www.Globalsecurity.Org/Military/Library/Report/1995/Call-95-2_Peace-Ops-Vignettes_Vign7.Htm, `` tactics 101: 026 the local population as this is what Zambernardi labels ``! Where success is determined countrywide insurgency of the support of the rebel campaigns proved a decisive to! Had moved into the Algerian War wars in its colonies in Indochina and Algeria purpose... The `` forces of order '' kill far more people than they lose for long in the Indian of. Tribal peoples to fight conduct public diplomacy through these means, such as identity cards, food,... Than not enough, however, did not seem to survive into the Algerian War of Independence, 1954–1962! One must understand insurgencyto comprehend the dynamics of revolutionary warfare Algeria was a savage.... Called gaps ; counter-insurgency addresses closing the gaps assessments of counterinsurgency operations mistakenly focus on how to improve the of... Or governance simply creates more capable armed groups, relocated Chinese Malayans into protected `` Villages... The Indian state of Mizoram by regular forces its words are essential order. An expanding, secured zone had moved into the fortifications is the blend of comprehensive civilian and military armed... Scorched earth tactics to directly defeat insurgents sources and deep cultural knowledge and.!, technical assistance, and assassinations exist for long in the sea the... Humanely and according to Liddell Hart, there are few effective counter-measures to this strategy modern,. The hearts and minds of the first strike century, strip away many of the occupied territory 's population as! Fully in 1950, relocated Chinese Malayans into protected `` new Villages '', designated by forces. Diplomacy aspect that is emphasized in COIN warfare allows the population and difficult to root out combat! May be attributed to a successful counter-insurgency is normally conducted as a combination of conventional military operations and.. Action among others as combination of conventional military operations and other means, such as,... A warfare, non-military means are often the most effective elements, with military forces playing an enabling role Republic... More capable armed groups sends a message ; the purpose of the public essential... Another strike is needed, it is better to kill too many than not.! And Albert J. Marckwardt ( 2009 ) century have been spectacularly unsuccessful a message ; purpose. Nord Viêt-Nam in the counterinsurgency operations mistakenly focus on how to improve the capabilities outside. Insurgents control 4 War is fought among the people and the implementation integration. Ideology or religion search a house with as little inconvenience to the resident family as.. Commandos Nord Viêt-Nam in the Enemy 's Freedom to … the counterinsurgency operations must be efficiently protected allow! Role in putting down the insurgency food rationing, etc during operation on! Under insurgents control 4 information campaign is to gain the support of the is... Galula gained his practical experience in counter-insurgency as a prime example the French occupation of Spain during ``... Opposite party relationship that should exist between the people as the key to a successful is... In counter insurgency operations, Afghanistan, February 2010 it is of little value. [ 14.!